With Antoine Semenyo heading to Manchester Metropolis, Liverpool’s determination to depart raises a severe query: did they miss a golden alternative to open up their assault for the long run, or is persistence the clever play within the post-Salah period?
Semenyo state of affairs: from Anfield reward to Etihad assist
Because the January 2026 switch window approaches, one of the vital fascinating tales is coming to an finish. Bournemouth’s explosive winger Antoine Semenyo is ready to hitch Manchester Metropolis. With Liverpool strongly linked in the beginning of the season, the query looms giant: did they miss a golden alternative to strengthen their assault, or did they miss making the suitable determination?
The reigning Premier League champions are stated to have made contact in November with a view to a possible transfer, however have remained silent since then, opening the door for different international locations to swoop in and benefit from such gamers out there within the winter market.
Semenyo’s rise is outstanding. The 25-year-old has turn out to be one of many Premier League’s most harmful large forwards. His numbers this season, with eight targets and three assists per 90 minutes, and a aim involvement fee of 0.69, underline his affect. His capability to function on both flank, mixed together with his velocity, energy and directness, makes him supreme for high-intensity methods.
With a £65m launch clause out there for the primary 10 days of January, Semenyo has a uncommon probability to safe a confirmed participant with out breaking into nine-figure territory.
The report claims he would have ‘jumped on the probability’ to hitch Liverpool if that they had made the transfer official. When it grew to become clear that they might not, Semenyo selected Manchester Metropolis over different suitors, specifically Manchester United, Chelsea and Tottenham Hotspur.
Why Liverpool’s curiosity makes good sense
Liverpool’s preliminary curiosity was comprehensible. Mohamed Salah, the membership’s talisman for almost a decade, is now not the unstoppable drive he as soon as was. After a record-setting 2024-25 season, his efficiency declined precipitously. Objectives per 90 fell from 0.80 to 0.29, anticipated targets per 90 halved and touches contained in the opposition field fell by greater than a 3rd.
At 33, Salah’s decline is comprehensible and has been exacerbated by tactical modifications underneath supervisor Arne Slott and a public row wherein he accused the membership of “throwing him underneath the bus”. Whether or not it’s leaving for Saudi Arabia in 2026 or extending his contract till 2027, Liverpool should plan for all times after Salah and his life within the close to future.
Semenyo appeared like the proper bridge to that future. He has a confirmed observe report within the Premier League, is stylistically much like Salah’s outspoken angle and might be acquired for a price that appears cheap in at the moment’s inflationary market.
Why Liverpool left
So why did Liverpool pull out? Monetary prudence is one clarification. The membership spent closely on the signings of Alexander Isak, Florian Wirtz and Hugo Ekitike final summer time, and will have been reluctant to make one other huge spend halfway by way of the season, particularly with FFP restrictions in thoughts.
There’s additionally the difficulty of squad routing. Liverpool are eager to guard the event of 17-year-old winger Rio Ngmoha, who’s already incomes first-team minutes. Blocking his progress by signing a marquee participant may jeopardize their long-term plans.
And there is additionally technique. Liverpool’s leaders reportedly view Semenyo as a short-term repair slightly than a transformational signing. Their eyes are firmly on younger, high-ceiling skills equivalent to RB Leipzig’s Yann Diomande, who’s being touted as Salah’s eventual successor. In the long run, Semenyo would have welcomed a transfer to Liverpool, however as soon as that choice was exhausted, his alternative of Manchester Metropolis was an apparent one, given the lure of trophies and Guardiola’s venture.
motive for remorse
However strolling away comes with dangers. Liverpool’s assault is slowing down. Salah’s type is declining, Isak is out for an prolonged time period and Kodi Gakpo and Wertz are struggling to keep up consistency.
On this context, Semenyo may have supplied fast affect and tactical flexibility. His capability to run behind the sector will complement a possession-oriented system within the slot and add the fast risk it presently lacks.
Moreover, £65m for a confirmed Premier League ahead appears like good worth in comparison with continental targets who can command charges in extra of €100m.
Embed from Getty Pictures
persistence required
Quite the opposite, restraint could show to be clever in the long term. Liverpool’s rebuild has already begun, with Isak, Wirtz and Ekitike forming the spine of their forward-looking assault. Spending some huge cash on Semenyo, who turns 26 subsequent 12 months, may restrict the assets of an elite younger prospect.
Slots’ philosophy emphasizes managed evolution slightly than reactive spending. If Liverpool actually imagine signing Diomande or Rodrygo has the next ceiling, then ready till the summer time is in keeping with their long-term imaginative and prescient. Nonetheless, the fee might be considerably increased.
Verdict: A calculated gamble
So did Liverpool miss their probability? Sure, it’s doable if the indicator is short-term revenue. Semenyo would have strengthened his title problem and eased the transition from Salah. However when seen within the broader context of succession planning, Liverpool’s determination displays strategic self-discipline slightly than laziness.
The guess is on the execution. If Salah leaves and Liverpool fail to signal a world-class alternative earlier than the summer time, this lock-up will appear to be a idiot’s errand. If they’ll safe generational expertise, taking on from Semenyo shall be seen as a visionary transfer.
For now, Manchester Metropolis seem prepared so as to add one other highly effective weapon to Guardiola’s arsenal. Liverpool, however, should hope that their persistence shall be rewarded. As a result of in trendy soccer, the road between warning and paralysis is dangerously skinny.
